Solar and Battery System
Illustrative case Fictional example
This fictional business case is not based on a real site, utility, incentive program, jurisdiction, or completed engagement. All figures are rounded 2026 USD assumptions that require validation before commitment.
- Domain
- Commercial energy infrastructure
- Delivery approach
- Stage-gated, then predominantly predictive
- Scenario
- Compare grid-only supply, a power purchase agreement, and an owned solar-and-battery system for a distribution center.
- Decision sought
- Approve feasibility development and a conditional path to procurement of the owned-system option.
- Investment scale
- USD 180,000 development; USD 3.40 million gross project ceiling
- Planning horizon
- 15 years from commercial operation
- Primary constraints
- Structural capacity, grid connection, incentive certainty, tariff sensitivity, procurement, and commissioning.
- Evidence basis
- Illustrative load, tariff, degradation, replacement, incentive, and lifecycle-cost assumptions.
- Demonstrates
- Lifecycle energy economics, scenario sensitivity, commercial risk allocation, and conditional infrastructure investment.
Document Control
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Sponsor | Director, Distribution Operations |
| Business owner | Head of Facilities and Energy |
| Decision | Approve development and conditional procurement of the recommended option |
| Estimate class | Feasibility, ±20%; not a construction budget |
| Evaluation horizon | 15 years from commercial operation |
| Financial basis | Real, pre-tax cash flows; 6% real discount rate |
| Version / status | 1.0 / For approval |
| Issue / decision date | 24 August 2026 |
| Next review | G1 baseline gate or 24 October 2026, whichever occurs first |
Executive Summary
The distribution center is assumed to consume 8,000 MWh annually, peak at 2.2 MW, and spend approximately USD 1.68 million per year on electricity. The opportunity is a roof-mounted 1.5 MWdc solar array and a 1 MW/2 MWh battery, sized provisionally from representative load data. Three options were assessed: remain grid-only, enter a third-party power purchase agreement (PPA), or own the system.
The owned system is recommended, subject to defined stage gates. It has an estimated gross capital cost of USD 3.40 million, reduced to USD 2.60 million by an explicitly assumed USD 0.80 million incentive. It is expected to produce first-year gross savings of USD 464,000 and net operating benefit of USD 389,000. After degradation, battery replacement, inverter replacement, and end-of-life provisions, its base-case NPV is approximately USD 0.62 million and simple payback is seven years. Without the assumed incentive, NPV falls to approximately negative USD 0.18 million; therefore incentive confirmation is an approval condition, not a claimed entitlement.
Approval of up to USD 180,000 for development, within the gross project ceiling, is requested now. Construction release would follow interval-data, structural, interconnection, commercial, and final-investment stage gates.
Strategic Case and Energy Baseline
The project supports operating-cost control, reduced exposure to daytime energy prices, and measurable reduction in grid electricity consumption. It does not make the facility energy-independent. The base case assumes 12 months of representative half-hourly data will confirm the following illustrative baseline.
| Baseline item | Assumption |
|---|---|
| Annual consumption | 8,000 MWh |
| Peak demand | 2.2 MW |
| Energy charge | USD 0.16/kWh |
| Demand and other grid charges | USD 400,000/year |
| Total annual electricity cost | USD 1.68 million |
| Solar yield / first-year self-use | 2,100 MWh / 95% |
The grid-only cost has a 15-year present value of about USD 16.32 million if real tariffs and demand remain flat. This is a comparison baseline, not a utility-bill forecast.
Objectives and Success Measures
The project will reduce controllable electricity cost without impairing operations. Success will be assessed against the following criteria:
| Success criterion | Accountable owner role |
|---|---|
| Delivery within the approved cost ceiling and schedule | Project Director |
| First-year solar generation at least 95% of the independently validated P50 forecast | Head of Facilities and Energy |
| Solar self-consumption at least 90% in the first full operating year | Head of Facilities and Energy |
| Verified annual savings of at least USD 330,000 after the first full operating year | Finance Business Partner |
| Battery availability at least 97%, excluding agreed outages | Head of Facilities and Energy |
| No recordable safety incident during delivery and operation | Safety Manager |
| Monthly measurement against an adjusted interval baseline | Finance Business Partner |
Constraints and Dependencies
Roof loading, remaining life, fire access, insurer requirements, and load shape constrain sizing. The project depends on acceptable interconnection, permits, incentive eligibility, equipment availability, control cybersecurity approval, and continued occupancy. Demand growth is not assumed. Backup-power value is neither promised nor monetized; islanding requires separate equipment and critical-load evidence.
Options
- Grid-only: no project capital or execution disruption; retains full exposure to tariff changes and delivers no project energy reduction.
- Third-party PPA: provider finances, owns, and maintains solar and battery assets under an indicative 15-year contract. Annual real net benefit is estimated at USD 55,000 and NPV at roughly USD 0.53 million, subject to firm pricing and allocation of risks.
- Owned system: the company procures and owns 1.5 MWdc solar and 1 MW/2 MWh battery assets, controls dispatch, receives eligible incentives, and carries performance, maintenance, replacement, and end-of-life obligations.
Options Appraisal
| Criterion | Grid-only | PPA | Owned |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indicative 15-year NPV benefit vs grid | USD 0 | USD 0.53m | USD 0.62m |
| Initial company capital | Minimal | Minimal | USD 3.40m gross |
| Cost certainty | Low | Medium | Medium |
| Operational control | High utility dependence | Contract-limited | High |
| Delivery / asset risk | Low | Mostly provider, with exceptions | Company |
| Exit flexibility | High | Low | Medium |
The PPA remains a credible fallback, but its apparent risk transfer is incomplete. A term sheet must state who bears electricity-price basis risk, system underperformance, minimum purchase or take-or-pay volume, battery availability, curtailment by the grid or site, change-in-law and grid-charge risk, roof work, early termination, and end-of-term removal. Savings can disappear if a fixed escalator outpaces avoided tariffs or if the facility must buy contracted output it cannot use.
Recommended Option and Scope
Proceed with the owned system, while retaining the PPA as a competitive financing alternative through final investment decision. Scope includes PV modules, inverters, racking, a containerized battery, energy-management controls, protection and metering, interconnection works, monitoring, cybersecurity configuration, training, warranties, initial spares, and safe decommissioning provisions. Roof replacement, major utility network reinforcement, resilience/islanding, and unrelated electrical upgrades are excluded unless separately approved.
Financial Case
| Uses and benefits | Amount / assumption |
|---|---|
| Solar, racking, inverters, installation | USD 2.05m |
| Battery, controls, and installation | USD 0.95m |
| Design, interconnection, contingency | USD 0.40m |
| Gross CAPEX | USD 3.40m |
| Assumed incentive, received at completion | negative USD 0.80m |
| Net initial investment | USD 2.60m |
| Annual O&M, software, insurance | USD 75,000 |
| Battery replacement, year 9 | USD 600,000 |
| Inverter replacement, year 12 | USD 150,000 |
| Year-15 residual less decommissioning | USD 50,000 net |
First-year solar savings are 1,995 self-consumed MWh × USD 160/MWh = USD 319,200. Modeled battery demand and arbitrage savings are USD 145,000, producing gross savings of USD 464,200 and net year-one benefit of USD 389,200 after O&M. No outage avoidance or export revenue is included. Solar output degrades 0.5% annually. Battery economic benefit degrades 1.5% annually and resets after the year-nine replacement. The residual assumes equipment value of USD 300,000 less USD 250,000 removal and recycling cost; neither figure is guaranteed.
The owned-system NPV treats the net investment as a time-zero outflow, operating benefits and costs as year-end cash flows, replacements as year-end outflows, and the residual as a year-15 inflow. Discounting those cash flows at 6% gives an NPV of USD 0.62 million and a simple payback during year 7. The corresponding owned-system lifecycle cost is approximately USD 15.70 million versus USD 16.32 million grid-only. For the PPA, a flat USD 55,000 annual real benefit paid at each year-end for 15 years has a 6% present-value factor of 9.712, giving USD 534,000, rounded to USD 0.53 million, with no initial company investment assumed. Rounded sensitivities are:
| Scenario | NPV benefit vs grid |
|---|---|
| Base case | USD 0.62m |
| No incentive | negative USD 0.18m |
| Avoided tariff and grid value 20% lower | negative USD 0.25m |
| Avoided tariff and grid value 20% higher | USD 1.49m |
| Additional structural works of USD 0.40m | USD 0.22m |
| Demand 20% lower: 85% solar self-use and 20% lower battery value | USD 0.03m |
| Battery economic use only 50% of plan | negative USD 0.05m |
The lower-demand case is a simplified, reproducible sensitivity: annual solar generation remains 2,100 MWh, self-use falls from 95% to 85%, excess generation has no value, and battery demand-charge and arbitrage savings fall 20% from USD 145,000 to USD 116,000 in year one. Applying the base-case degradation, replacement, residual, and 6% discount assumptions gives an NPV of approximately USD 0.03 million. The decision is therefore most sensitive to tariffs and grid charges, incentive receipt, sustained facility demand, and effective battery dispatch. Structural cost is material but tolerable at the tested level. Battery controls will be tuned after commissioning using actual tariffs and operations; savings are not treated as certain until measured.
Commercial and Delivery Approach
Use an owner’s engineer to validate yield, structure, safety, and finances, followed by competitive design-and-build procurement with performance guarantees, liquidated damages, open controls data, cybersecurity requirements, and assignable warranties. Obtain long-term service and recycling prices. Implementation is largely predictive after feasibility: freeze design before construction, control changes, and use acceptance tests. Controls optimization is adaptive after commissioning, with guarded set-points that never override safety or warehouse priorities.
Milestones and Stage Gates
| Gate | Evidence required | Target from approval |
|---|---|---|
| G1 Baseline | 12-month interval data, tariff reconstruction, load forecast | Month 2 |
| G2 Feasibility | Structural survey, roof-life plan, fire/insurer review, P50 yield | Month 3 |
| G3 Grid | Interconnection study, protection scope, curtailment terms, cost cap | Month 5 |
| G4 Procurement / FID | Compliant bids, incentive confirmation, updated NPV ≥ USD 0, funding | Month 7 |
| G5 Construction | Approved design, permits, safety and outage plans | Month 9 |
| G6 Commissioning | Acceptance tests, metering, training, baseline controls | Month 15 |
| G7 Benefits | 90-day tuning and first-year measurement report | Months 18 / 27 |
Risks, Disbenefits, Responses
| Risk or disbenefit | Response |
|---|---|
| Roof strengthening or shortened roof life | Intrusive survey; coordinate roof warranty; stop at cost gate |
| Interconnection delay, cost, or curtailment | Apply early; cap exposure before equipment order |
| Fire, electrical, or battery thermal event | Listed equipment; separation, detection, emergency plan, responder review |
| Lower yield, tariff value, or battery savings | Independent model; guarantees; submetering; dispatch tuning |
| Construction disruption and roof access | Phased work, weather controls, agreed outage windows |
| Technology failure or supplier insolvency | Bankable suppliers, warranties, bonds, spares, step-in rights |
| Cyber compromise of controls | Segmentation, least privilege, logging, patch and incident obligations |
| End-of-life waste and cost | Fund provision; contractual take-back and certified recycling |
Benefits and Carbon Realization
Finance will verify savings from utility invoices and revenue-grade meters against an interval baseline adjusted for weather, operating hours, throughput, tariff changes, degradation, and curtailment. Sustainability will report on-site generation and grid electricity displaced. Any greenhouse-gas estimate will use the then-current, disclosed location-based grid factor and will be stated separately from contractual renewable claims. Avoided emissions will not be presented as zero-carbon electricity, and no certificate claim will be made unless ownership and retirement are documented.
Governance and Review Triggers
The sponsor chairs a monthly steering group with Operations, Facilities, Finance, Procurement, IT security, Safety, and Sustainability. Finance owns the benefits ledger; Facilities owns the asset; Operations approves outages and control constraints.
Return to the investment committee for reapproval if any of the following occurs:
- Forecast gross CAPEX exceeds the USD 3.40 million project ceiling; no overspend tolerance applies.
- Incentive value falls below USD 0.80 million.
- Modeled NPV becomes negative.
- Interconnection adds more than USD 250,000 or six months.
- Structural work exceeds USD 400,000.
- The demand forecast falls by 15% or more.
- A material scope, safety, PPA, or end-of-life assumption changes.
Decision Required and Approval Conditions
Approve the owned-system option and up to USD 180,000 of development expenditure, included within the USD 3.40 million ceiling. Authorize competitive procurement of both owned and PPA offers, but do not authorize construction until G4. Any forecast gross CAPEX above USD 3.40 million must return to the investment committee for reapproval before further commitment.
Final approval requires:
- Validated interval data.
- Acceptable structural and interconnection reports.
- Fixed or capped pricing within the USD 3.40 million project ceiling.
- Confirmation of the USD 0.80 million incentive.
- Base-case NPV of at least zero using Finance-approved assumptions.
- Executed performance and recycling obligations.
- Approved safety, cybersecurity, outage, and benefits-realization plans.