Failure Theories
Failure theories predict when a material will yield or fracture under complex (multi-axial) stress states.
Maximum Normal Stress Theory (Rankine)
Material fails when maximum principal stress exceeds tensile strength.
Conservative — good for brittle materials.
Maximum Shear Stress Theory (Tresca)
Material yields when maximum shear stress reaches shear stress at yield in tension.
- Simple and conservative
- Good for ductile materials
Distortion Energy Theory (Von Mises)
Material yields when distortional energy per unit volume equals distortional energy at yield in tension.
- Most accurate for ductile metals
- Widely used in FEA post-processing
Comparison
| Theory | Formula | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Rankine | max(σ₁, σ₃) | Brittle |
| Tresca | σ₁ - σ₃ | Ductile, conservative |
| Von Mises | √[(σ₁-σ₂)²+(σ₂-σ₃)²+(σ₃-σ₁)²]/2 | Ductile, accurate |
2D Stress State
For plane stress (σ_z = 0):
Von Mises (in-plane)
Tresca (in-plane)
Mohr's Failure Theory
Uses Mohr's circle to define a failure envelope based on tension and compression test data.
- Most general theory
- Can handle different tensile and compressive strengths
- Used for composite materials, rocks, soils
Failure Criteria Summary
For ductile materials under static loading:
- Von Mises — best overall accuracy
- Tresca — more conservative, simpler
- Maximum normal stress — brittle materials only